Saturday, November 19, 2005

Outrageous Hypocrites

"Our society should liberate itself from the ideas such as the one that women should have their virginity intact when getting married. No educated man will expect the woman he marries to be a virgin." – Kushboo 'Tamil Protection Movement' led by PMK seems convinced that we must become a Talibanesque society. The above statement is supposedly "against our culture” and some jobless idiots filed a defamation suit against Kushboo. Instead of poking fun at the petitioners the local court in Mettur issued a warrant against her and now she is out on bail. Atleast she did not commit a non-bailable crime! While it is obvious that the politicians are using the situation to gain mileage, I am shocked at how majority of people have responded. Especially the reaction of a section of the dalit womenfolk here is atrocious. Instead of celebrating Kushboo’s statement as a small step towards genuine emancipation for Tamil women we have women’s groups in Madurai holding public demonstrations against her! Even here in Madras a lot of supposedly forward thinking people seem to have taken offence to her remarks. I want to ask them – what is this great Indian culture you are trying to preserve? Did the sculptures in Kajuraho dating from a much earlier period rise from thin air? Where did this book called Kamasutra, which the west embraced, originate from? Who the hell are you to decide what other men and women should say and do? I hope they know this whole thing of moral policing of women came with the Mughal and British invasions of India. Do I need to even go into the lusty pursuits of household Indian mythological heroes? I know that what Kushboo said is representative of a substantial number of people, especially young women in our city. And if most men and some women in our state have a problem accepting this TOO BAD! When you see a matrimonial add where the groom in waiting seeks “a fair, homely, ________(the blank is filled with the caste name) girl, with an attractive slim body, who does not want to work" the word vulgar takes on a whole new meaning. These atrocious fools get away with BULL**** like that while Kushboo is being harassed for speaking out on behalf of urban Indian women. For the first time in my life I feel ashamed to say that I am a resident of Madras. A Madras where a woman cant speak her mind out. I support Kushboo in her hour of need and so must you.

20 comments:

ada-paavi!!!! said...

nice post, da, well as u said there is political milage, but its also a kind of tit for tat. the DPIs way of saying that the others cant mess with them, which seems to play a more important role than the issue of tamil culture.
this has given them visual media space which they so desprately lacked

AG said...

Hi.. nice way of looking at it actually.. But again, you must realize that we are in a country where pre-marital sex is considered a taboo.. We are NOT in europe or america where such things are common.. One more thing.. This comment really pertains to a very small section of the society - those who try to ape the western culture with regard to these practices.. Firstly, I dont see why she had to make such a comment out of no where.. and secondly.. its her wish.. She can say whatever she wants.. It is a bit funny that an arrest warrant had to be issued for such a silly thing..
I dont vehemently oppose her statement n all but I feel such things should remain within the closet..

Jeevan said...

Well writen, there was a big group in this socity to put a case and struggle for simple thinks.

Manasi Subramaniam said...

Ajit,

You might want to try and remember the circumstances under which she made that statement. Seriously. I cannot believe that you are so narrow-minded that you think that her opinion was unwarranted. Read the newspapers.

jack said...

Completely agree.great post.Check out my take on this.

jack said...

i blog rolled you.

Klingsor said...

I can´t speak for Tamil Nadu, but I know from other societies: Often the same people who insist on the virginity of a bride want the bridegroom to be "experienced" - also in sexual ways. But with whom he could have made these sexual experiences when all the women are either married or not allowed to have sex? Surely these people also condemn prostitution, don´t they? So this situation is quit schizophren..

AG said...

Sorry Manasi if I've got it all wrong.. Actually, I haven't read the news papers for a loooong time now.. Jus heard by word of mouth from someone about this.. I agree with her stand on the enforcement of dress code which is really quite absurd.
About my opinion on her comments regarding virginity, less said the better... It's not really a question of being narrow-minded.. Ppl HAVE mocked at me for my opinion on such issues.. I guess I'm yet to get out of my amateurish attitude.. That's the kind of atmosphere I've been brought up in at home and so that's how I will be...

Raju said...

Sid, though I support her and what she and Suhasini are trying to say, our people are not in the right mindset to listen to them.. And the Dalit women play to the tune of their 'leader'.

Anonymous said...

Hey Nice arguments. I apologise if this sounds patronising but I am elated that this controversy has exposed the many liberal minds in India.

Hypocritic India needs a good self-check. I am tired and sick of the moralizing act of many politicians. I wonder how many politicians and the self-styled moral police will pass if their personal lives are scrutinized.

Ajit, please realise that Khusboo probably criticised this because it was a taboo. Taboos are what they are - an act frowned upon because some-people wrongly assume a moral slant to it when there is none - and because of this they warrant criticism.

Blabber-blogger said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Blabber-blogger said...

First timer here.

Very well written post. Persuasive in putting forth your strong convinction. Great to read it.

Its so rediculously stupid to even argue anything against. Lot of them feel its an insult to the indian women.. She didnt mean to suggest so. Whatever be the case, an indian girl should be given the same freedom of choice and respect as any one else. More so..lot of these indian men with loud mouths need to educate themselves better about simple things like women's health to begin with. I am sure they have absolutely no clue abt woman's physiology.

Something like this is really annoying..

Ram C said...

there was a good article in the latest "A.vikatan" by Gnani - about the interpretation of these kind of free thoughts.

He was questioning the authority of few organisations like PMK or Thirumavalavan, who said to be representing Tamil people.. when they couldn't accept Suhasini representing Tamil people to apologize to Kushboo.

It seems, several suits have been filed against Suhasini also....

SV said...

Ha- Tamil protection movement it seems... thoo !

Anonymous said...

Lets not get carried away people. Think about it !
This is not an issue where your egoes would come out in support of one side or the other.
Here are a couple of things I would like to point out:

What Kushboo said was right and wrong.
Its right in the sense that she advocated "safe sex" ***publicly*** which is perfectly fine and something that has to be appreciated BUT she need not have made a statement like ""pre-marital sex is fine and no educated man would expect his bride to be a virgin"" in as many words. This has some dire consequences. Freedom of speech does not mean you can make some irresponsible statements and ignite passion(even accidentally) for no rhyme or reason.
This is uncalled for mainly because though the people who have had pre-marital sex before would continue to do so (and may get enouraged more to do it infact), but as a public statement this may lead to people who have not indulged in pre-marital sex think that this is cool and hep and "in times with others" and may get indulged in it without knowing what they are getting into or without having enough maturity to handle the "after". She need not have made the second statement at all and I feel that it is not "casual" given that she is a celebrity and it MAY happen that some kids may take her seriously just to "try it out".
My take is: Pre-marital sex is fine as long as it is protected and safe and both the boy and girl know exactly what they are getting into, as simple as that.
- So what is the difference ??? ---> I stopped short of saying uncalled for statements such as "no educated man would expect his bride to be a virgin". And this is precisely where the problem erupted if you look at it.

Its very important that a public figure should never make an irresponsible statement on the name of freedom of speech. It may cause chaos both on the boy/girl as well their parents mind leading to a diluted security and apprehensions. I seriously felt that there was NO NEED for rasing the VIRGIN issue while advocating SAFE SEX. Its a very delicate topic both for boys and girls.
Its fine if you think my views are a bit outdated, but think again.

As for the reaction of the tamilnadu political parties and media highlighting this in the way they did, I sincerely condemn it with they publicizing it even more and making a mountain out a non-issue just to meet their own ends meet.

Let me know if anybody has any comments on my views.

anand

eyeStreet times said...

Its a waste of time. Seems there are lots of jobless politicians with lots of lung power.

Move On.

Anonymous said...

If they want a Talaban type situation then look out Sidd ! Why must a woman be a virgin and a man be experienced ?

GB said...

Hahaha...I've been quite amused over this issue really. Nobody seems to be asking women, tamil or not, in the premarital age group [say 18-25] if they feel violated at all. I firmly believe that any kind of sex is permissible as long as it is consensual. If it happens to be extra-marital, it is sufficient grounds for divorce and that's that. Otherwise, I don't see why anybody should have a problem with it.

eyeStreet times said...

Kushboo's comment is something our society should debate about and not protest or riot about.

The jury is still out there and we should wait for the verdict !!

Kanishkaa said...

You were bang on.nice aggression.It's not just her comments..the dress code issue,banning dancing in night clubs etc,we can safely say this so called culture has gone to the DOGS.